Rome asks Kyiv for answers
The Italian foreign ministry said on Wednesday, 18 November, that Antonio Tajani had asked the ambassador in Kyiv to approach Ukrainian authorities for an explanation of why Five Star Movement members of the European Parliament were placed on a list of "anti-Ukrainians" on the Myrotvorets website. On 19 November Il Fatto Quotidiano reported that Matteo Salvini, deputy prime minister and leader of the League, also appears on the same list. Myrotvorets is run by a Ukrainian non-governmental organisation founded in 2014 and publishes a database of people its operators regard as enemies of Ukraine, sometimes with photos and personal details. Ansa first reported seven affected MEPs from several nationalities, and later reported that the entire Five Star delegation in the European Parliament was on the list. Il Fatto Quotidiano also reports that the site has links to Ukraine's security service, the SBU, and to members of the current Ukrainian government.
- Roberto Vannacci's photo is added to the Myrotvorets list, per Il Fatto Quotidiano
- Italian foreign ministry says Tajani asked the ambassador in Kyiv to seek clarification
- Salvini says his name is on the list and demands clarification from Kyiv
What the list says
According to Il Fatto Quotidiano, the entries accuse listed people of attempting to violate Ukraine's territorial integrity, of supporting Russian propaganda and of denying Russian aggression. Roberto Vannacci, founder of Futuro Nazionale, is also on the list, and his photo has been there since July, with the entry calling him an 'anti-Ukrainian propagandist'. The paper names other listed politicians including Robert Fico, Viktor Orban, Jean-Luc Melenchon and Marine Le Pen. Danilo Della Valle, the first Five Star MEP to be named, is accused of taking part in humanitarian aggression against Ukraine and of spreading Russian propaganda. Della Valle says that in the past week six or seven more MEPs from all political groups have been added to the list.
Salvini and the League respond
Speaking on Tg2 Post, Salvini said he had learned with concern that his name appeared on the list.
I learned with dismay that my name appears in a disturbing proscription list.
He demanded immediate clarification from the Ukrainian government and institutions and said the League would draw its own conclusions if none arrived. He also linked the matter to the coming vote on extending aid to Ukraine, arguing that Italy should not help a government that does not distance itself from a site that labels journalists and politicians as enemies of the people.
I expect an apology from Zelensky.
Lega MEP group leader Paolo Borchia called the affair disturbing and asked Kyiv to say who drew up the lists.
Kiev must immediately clarify who drew up these lists, with what authority and on the basis of what evidence.
Lega figure Borghi called for a halt to arms shipments, and Dreosto announced a parliamentary question.
Della Valle and the European Parliament
Della Valle wrote to European Parliament president Roberta Metsola asking for a procedure to defend parliamentary immunity and his freedom of political opinion, and asked her to press Ukrainian authorities through diplomatic channels to have his name removed, according to Ansa. As of the Fatto interview he had received no formal reply from Metsola, only a statement from the parliament's press office. Officials from the parliament's DG Safe visited his office on Monday, told him there was no imminent danger, and said they would look further into the case. Della Valle described the parliament's response as weak and said it had passed largely unnoticed.
Wider context in Rome
Ukrainska Pravda describes Della Valle as a critic of arms deliveries to Ukraine, and Ansa reported that around 91 per cent of Five Star members voted against continuing those deliveries in a September internal ballot. Greens and Left MEPs from AVS expressed solidarity with their Five Star colleagues and asked the European Parliament to act to protect their freedom of expression. The foreign ministry said Tajani was following the affair closely and that freedom of expression and political pluralism must always be protected.
