A plan announced in Vienna
On Monday, 16 November, Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece and the Netherlands presented a plan to send rejected asylum-seekers to Rwanda. The announcement came at a migration conference in Vienna, where Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker hosted a joint press conference with Rwanda's interior minister, Vincent Biruta, seated in the centre of the stage. Germany's interior minister Alexander Dobrindt took part in the talks alongside his counterparts from the other countries. Reports differ on how far the deal has progressed: one account describes a signed agreement on a first return hub, while a Swiss report describes only a declaration of intent, with the details still to be negotiated over the coming months.
- UNHCR begins moving Africans from Libya to Rwanda
- Britain abandons its deal to deport asylum-seekers to Rwanda
- Five EU states and Rwanda present the return hub plan in Vienna
- Planned start of a pilot for about 100 rejected asylum-seekers
How the hubs would work
The so-called return hubs are meant for people whose asylum claims have been refused, who are legally obliged to leave the EU, but whom their countries of origin will not take back. The first site would be in Rwanda, and the pilot is planned for about 100 people. One report says the pilot can begin only in summer 2027, while Greek reporting says first transfers are possible in 2027. Uganda is also being considered as a possible partner.
The five governments would fund the hubs together, and they are weighing incentives for host countries such as financial aid and trade deals. Greek Migration Minister Thanos Plevris argued that the centres would not be closed detention facilities and that responsibility would be shared rather than pushed onto host nations.
Whoever is not entitled to asylum should return to their country of origin.
Plevris also called the arrangement with Rwanda a win-win relationship and said the benefits for Greece would be significant. Operational details are still to be worked out, beginning with a road map.
Rwanda's offer and earlier precedents
Biruta said Rwanda offers a 'second chance' to people expelled from Europe. He added that those who choose to stay would be integrated into local communities and given training so they can work. Rwanda has already taken in migrants from Libya since 2019, when the UN refugee agency UNHCR, the African Union and the Rwandan government agreed to fly them out of detention there. About 3,000 Africans have been brought to Rwanda since then, and they are housed in the Gashora transit centre, about 50 kilometres south of Kigali, which has around 700 beds.
Earlier European attempts to outsource asylum have failed. Britain's plan to deport people who crossed the Channel to Rwanda was declared unlawful by its Supreme Court, and Prime Minister Keir Starmer declared it dead after Labour's win in July 2024. London had paid about 700 million pounds to Rwanda under the deal, and only four people had moved there voluntarily. In Italy, courts halted transfers from Albania shortly after the camps opened there.
Criticism and reactions
The UN human rights office said it was concerned about the planned transfers to a country that the people involved have no real link with, and noted that Rwanda faces its own human rights challenges. Ciaran Wrons-Passmann, director of the Berlin-based ecumenical network önz, said sending people to a third country that would take charge of them is very problematic from a human rights perspective. Inside Germany, SPD parliamentarian Rasha Nasr said the project had not been agreed within the coalition with the CDU and CSU, and that she opposes deporting people to what she called a dictatorship. Dobrindt sees no problem with the disagreement, saying the plan implements EU law made possible by the reform of the asylum system.
Switzerland watches closely
The Swiss State Secretariat for Migration told CH Media that it had noted the developments with interest. If the project proves successful and can be implemented legally and in practice, Switzerland would examine taking part. A study commissioned by the secretariat found that shifting asylum procedures and removals abroad would be legally possible, but would involve considerable hurdles and risks, including rule-of-law standards, high start-up costs and dependence on partner states. The study recommends a limited pilot with other European countries, and the Federal Council has said it will keep examining any models that meet rule-of-law standards.