Expert challenges the suicide finding
Forensic scientist Michael Freeman presented his conclusions in London on Monday, 16 November. He has worked on high-profile cases for US attorneys general, including the death of George Floyd. Freeman told BBC Newsnight that, after reviewing the New York medical examiner's autopsy file, he believes Epstein was assaulted, struck in the face and strangled, probably from behind. He did not examine the body himself and based his conclusions on documents and photographs supplied by Epstein's younger brother, Mark.
Freeman says the injuries and the way the body was found do not fit a self-inflicted death. He describes a deep but interrupted furrow around the neck, a deep bleed in the left shoulder and wounds under the jaw. He also reads fine scratches beside the neck mark as nail marks, which he takes as an attempt by Epstein to loosen the cord. Freeman told The Times that the chance of suicide was zero, given the circumstances recorded by the official examiner.
There's only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide.
The 2019 ruling
Epstein was found dead on 10 August 2019 in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York, where he was awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges. The pathologist who carried out the autopsy the following day concluded that the death was suicide and found no defensive wounds. Barbara Sampson, chief medical examiner at the time, stood by that conclusion in earlier remarks, and the BBC has asked her for a fresh response. A Department of Justice report four years later found no credible evidence of foul play, and the official finding has not changed since.
Mark Epstein and the file
Mark Epstein, a 72-year-old property developer, has argued for years that his brother was murdered. He handed the autopsy file to Freeman in November 2025 and has given many interviews, typically with his camera turned off. In January he told NewsNation:
I want to know who killed him and on whose behalf.
Freeman has published the autopsy material online, including 163 photographs from the autopsy, the autopsy report, photographs of the place where Epstein was found and a transcript of a call to the 911 emergency line. The publication is meant to let people reach their own conclusions, Freeman has said.
- Epstein found dead in his cell at a New York jail while awaiting trial
- Mark Epstein hands the autopsy file to Michael Freeman
- Freeman presents his findings in London
What remains open
Freeman's analysis has not been peer reviewed and has not yet been assessed by other experts. He says Mark Epstein did not pay him for the work. Two researchers, Itiel Dror and Anders Eriksson, took part in the evaluation, and the team aims to publish in a peer-reviewed journal. The assessment is independent and is not a new official finding by US authorities, so the 2019 suicide ruling still stands. The BBC has asked Barbara Sampson for a new response, and none had been reported in the articles at the time of writing.