Data protection probe in Hesse

Hesse's data protection authority has opened an investigation into Deutsche Bank after a leak of about 15 million internal records. The state commissioner, Alexander Roßnagel, is examining whether the bank had adequate safeguards for personal data, whether it reported the leak in time and whether it informed the affected people without delay. Possible breaches of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) are under review, and Roßnagel has asked the bank for further information and documents. The bank says it alerted the relevant authorities as a precaution and contacted customers and employees who could be affected. The probe was first reported by Handelsblatt and confirmed by the commissioner's office on 18 November.

Allegations of weak controls

Media outlets that analysed the material say it includes more than nine million emails, alongside reports, presentations and calendar entries. A consortium led by the Financial Times, with Der Spiegel, Le Monde, Paper Trail Media, ZDF and The New York Times among its partners, reports that the bank neglected anti-money-laundering controls for years in favour of profit. In Colombia, the bank's local subsidiary handled about 60% of all euro payments in the country during the first decade of this century, according to the reporting. A 2020 internal review codenamed "Project Cali" reportedly found thousands of high-risk transactions run through correspondent banking. In a single year, more than 20 billion in transactions for Colombia's main banks passed through, while the bank filed fewer than 10 suspicious activity reports. US-appointed external monitors criticised a "shocking lack of urgency" in the controls.

Russia, Epstein and Trump

According to the investigation, the bank kept expanding in Russia until 2021 despite internal warnings, and it announced its withdrawal only in March 2022, after Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The reporting says a list of "most sensitive clients" included the energy company Gazprom, the petrochemical group Sibur and Oleg Deripaska. Separately, nearly 600 million dollars in suspicious payments linked to Jeffrey Epstein were processed, a sum well above what had been known before. According to Reuters, the bank has lent Donald Trump more than two billion dollars since the 1990s. In spring 2017, a bank employee mistakenly sent financial documents for 1,586 accounts to a tax adviser in Maine, according to ZDF. Three of those accounts belonged to Trump, who had only been in office for a few weeks. The bank reported the incident to US authorities but did not inform Trump, a decision that Christian Sewing, then head of private clients and now chief executive, signed off on.

Key dates in the Deutsche Bank leak coverage
  1. Documents for 1,586 accounts, three of them Trump's, sent by mistake to a tax adviser in Maine
  2. Internal review Project Cali flags high-risk correspondent-banking transactions in Colombia
  3. Bank announces it will exit the Russian market
  4. Deutsche Bank shares fall as much as 6.2%, temporarily to 30.88 euros
  5. Hesse data protection authority opens investigation into the bank

When asked about the error during a trip to Manila, Trump said the bank should not have disclosed it.

They shouldn't have done it. It's illegal for them to do it.

— Donald Trump

Deutsche Bank declined to comment on Trump's reaction.

Market reaction and the bank's response

On Tuesday, 17 November, Deutsche Bank shares fell as much as 6.2%, temporarily to 30.88 euros, making it the weakest performer on the DAX by a wide margin. Jochen Stanzl, chief market analyst at Consorsbank, told Reuters that the revelations were not helpful for the share price in the short term. He said the first investor reaction under uncertainty is to sell, and that it is not yet possible to know whether the reporting will bring further legal or regulatory risks. The bank says the matters date back many years, were investigated at the time and that it worked closely with regulators. It does not expect significant financial consequences. Sewing told Handelsblatt that, in hindsight, other priorities could have been set, and he rejected the accusation of knowingly pushing risks aside. He said:

I am not free of mistakes.

— Christian Sewing

In an interview with Bild, Sewing said the bank had changed enormously over the past eight years, in profitability, stability, controls and corporate culture.